Reflective Silence or Normal Bus Behavior After a Tough Loss?
Published On: May 31, 2025This week I saw that a parent on a social channel asked a question something like, “when a team fights hard for a win and then loses (and has had a losing season), what should happen on the bus ride home? Should the kids be told to sit in quiet reflection or should they carry on with their normal behavior – laughing, talking, etc.?” I asked ChatGPT for some answers and below you’ll see what came back.
As with any coaching scenarios, the answer here is not black and white – it’s grey and depends on the situation, coaching style, maturity of the kids, and the moment.
---------------
A coach should guide the team's behavior on the bus ride home in a way that reflects the team's culture, the context of the loss, and the developmental stage of the players. Here’s a breakdown of both approaches, and what may work best depending on the situation:
As with any coaching scenarios, the answer here is not black and white – it’s grey and depends on the situation, coaching style, maturity of the kids, and the moment.
---------------
A coach should guide the team's behavior on the bus ride home in a way that reflects the team's culture, the context of the loss, and the developmental stage of the players. Here’s a breakdown of both approaches, and what may work best depending on the situation:
Option 1: Quiet Reflection
When it's appropriate:
- After a particularly tough or important loss (e.g., a championship game or a game they should have won).
- When players are emotional or visibly affected.
- If the team needs to learn how to process defeat maturely.
Why:
- Encourages players to reflect on their performance individually and collectively.
- Reinforces that losing isn’t just "business as usual" — it's a moment to learn.
- Helps maintain a level of respect for the competition and for teammates who may be more affected.
Implementation:
- Coach sets the tone: “Let’s use this time to think about what we can take from today. Tomorrow we’ll talk more and get back to work.”
Option 2: Normal Behavior (Talking, Laughing, Light Mood)
When it’s appropriate:
- If the loss was hard-fought and the team gave their best effort.
- In developmental or youth sports, where the primary goal is growth and fun.
- If the team already discussed the game and lessons post-game.
Why:
- Reminds players that one loss doesn’t define them or their season.
- Prevents wallowing and encourages resilience.
- Reinforces that relationships and team spirit persist beyond wins and losses.
Implementation:
- Coach might say, “Tough one today, but I’m proud of the fight. Let’s regroup tomorrow. For now, unwind and enjoy the ride home.”
Balanced Approach (Recommended)
Most often, a brief quiet period for reflection, followed by a return to normal interaction, works best.
Why:
- It honors the seriousness of competition and gives space for personal accountability.
- It prevents a loss from dominating the team’s identity or energy for too long.
- It models emotional regulation — acknowledging disappointment without being consumed by it.
What a coach might say:
“Let’s take the first 15 minutes to think about today — what went well, what we could have done better. After that, relax and be with your teammates. We’ll get better from this.”
Final Thoughts:
The key is intentionality — the ride home isn’t just downtime, it’s part of the coaching process. The coach sets the emotional tone. Players will follow that lead. Whether it’s reflection or levity, it should always point toward growth, accountability, and resilience.